The Pencil Borrowers

By William Gladstone

Unlike most objects of childhood memory, the tree still stood as it always had, a wide and tall projection of earth, dwarfing the surrounding landscape; a home to endless winged and scampering creatures; the center of space and time and existence of all Buck Valley. On countless occasions, I balanced on the gnarled roots, leapt for the lowest of braches, ran my hands along an ever-expanding trunk to discover new knobs and nooks and crevices where a boy could lodge treasures and secrets to keep hidden indefinitely from the eyes of the world; the tree would never tell, and God was busy elsewhere.

More true to task, and in keeping with the realities of an undusted remembrance, the walk from the gate, up the hill and to the front door of the Mills' home — where for eight years each Monday at 4:30, I dutifully trudged to take piano lessons from the lady of the house — were much smaller in proportion. The uneven paving stones could be covered in a span of less than a minute as the hill lazily rolled, hardly the mountain it had once been; and the house itself, though in most every other way pristine in my recollection, down to the ivy, was at least one tenth the size I had believed it twenty-odd years earlier. I was scarcely fourteen the last time I made that journey, feeling emancipated, feeling unburdened, feeling sick at heart.

I loved her, the Mills' oldest daughter. The highlight and the most excruciating torture of each lesson, more pleasing than a gold star, more humiliating than a rebuke for unlearned pieces, the length and breadth of all that was musical and meaningful in my world, summed up by an auburn bob, freckled nose and the artificial scent of strawberries: Natalie.

We shared classes throughout our school career and, due to the proximity of our names, I was blessed by her closeness, learning all there was to know by the repetition of casual observance and the sheer desire to absorb every stripe of her dresses and every strain of her voice. She bit her nails over long division, hummed during vocabulary tests, and shook her right leg nervously whenever called upon, though there was no need; she always had the correct answer. If perfection could be achieved at eight, twelve or fourteen, she had done so with overflowing success. So secretly wrapped up was I in her sighs and sneezes and shoulders slouched over her books, I failed to notice, or care, that her teeth were crooked and she laughed like a duck fussing the water.

By junior high we were casual acquaintances, pencil borrowers and nothing more. When I saw her each Monday before or after my piano lesson, we would exchange civilities, perhaps chat idly about a book report or protest harmlessly over an excessive work load of math; but I could never crack the bone and get to the marrow, the heart of the matter, to the eternal flush upon my face whenever she was near. She must have thought I was constantly in the sun, perpetually burnt but never tanned. She could not know, could not possibly understand the raging, coursing feelings running me at once hot and cold, making me light in the head, wobbly in the knees, tongue-tied and more foolish than I should have been. These were sensations I felt without cause or explanation, simply the reaction of her presence, her being, the catalyst of unexplainable emotion.

The tree lay just within the Mills' property line, branches reaching well up and over the fence, shading as much as half of Stipe Street, spilling out toward the house, the roots spreading wide and peaking up in all places, buckling the sidewalk; playing trespass into Mr. Reinhout's yard, where they wreaked havoc with his latticed scuppernongs and goose berries. I often loitered beneath its bows after lessons, listless and bothered, wondering what had taken hold of me, imagining what she was doing back up at the house: homework, television, setting the table for supper. Or, perhaps, as anxious as myself, hidden behind a curtained window, watching, building up nerve to walk down and join me, eventually falling short of the task or appearing only when I had given up hope and trailed home with dusk, defeated for another day.