Spitting Water

Directed by Joshua Neth, 2008
Cast: Troy Brokenshire, Sarah Milicia, Joshua Neth, Cheryl Moritz


Review by P. Pratt

Spitting Water, an Eric Leadbetter film presented by Choch-Key Productions, premiered recently at Home and Planet in South Side Bethlehem. This independent film was directed by Joshua Neth and filmed in the Lehigh Valley area with forty-three local actors.

Spitting Water is the story of a woman who is caretaker for her 35-year-old brain-damaged brother. The car crash that kills their parents, orphans the children, and leaves Danny (played as an adult by Troy Brokenshire) brain-damaged opens the film off-screen, and is depicted throughout the film by Danny's drawings.

Now an adult, Trudy (Sarah Milici) works at home as a specialty baker so that she can take care of her brother. Although her entire adult life has been spent caring for her brother, she has a good support system in Joshua Neth and Cheryl Moritz, who give strong performances as loving friends Ben and Margot. These characters are necessary, as the film deals with the death of Trudy's relationship with the cheating Ryan, her search for love in spite of her responsibilities, and the birth of a new life with Doug, a local florist.

The title refers to Danny's habit of spitting water, usually taken from the plastic bottle he habitually carries with him. Danny's link to water — in the bath, with his swimming therapy, and the ever-present plastic water bottle — provides a strong theme that ties some characters together, pushes others apart, leads to tragedy, and ultimately to self-forgiveness for Trudy after Danny's tragic death.

Troy Brokenshire's performance as the brain-damaged Danny is spot on, and absolutely necessary for the viewer to understand the love, frustration and protectiveness of his sister. Sarah Milici tries hard in an overwritten part that doesn't succeed as well as the enjoyable minor characters, most of whom were obviously written with love. Trudy just has too many expository lines of dialogue. The role of the married swimming therapy teacher who becomes gradually involved with Danny (Danny spying on the teacher after a shower, a careful kiss by the teacher and a grope by the inexperienced Danny in the pool after a successful lesson) was predictable. The film needed to provided a clear indication of the change in the teacher's feelings toward Danny, which sets off the final action of the film.

This is not a polished film, and some parts don't quite do what the director obviously intends, but it's enjoyable, nonetheless, as a snapshot of friendship in good times and bad.

Rating (out of 4): ** 1/2

Rated R (there is male frontal nudity in the death scene), 90 minutes